They're On Your Email List. Now What? How to Build a Welcome Sequence That Converts (for Equine Businesses)
- 4 hours ago
- 5 min read
Welcome to the show notes! Remember, this is a brief summary from the How to Market Your Horse Business podcast. You'll want to listen to the entire episode for all the good stuff!
You got the notification. Maybe even did a little internal fist pump. Getting someone onto your email list is worth the celebration. Every person counts.
But, now what?
What happens next? What do you actually say to them?
And more importantly, how do you turn that new subscriber into a paying client?
Because if all you’re doing is collecting email addresses, you don’t have a marketing strategy.
You have a list that’s sitting there doing nothing for your business.
Today, we’re going to fix that.
Do You Actually Need Email Marketing for Your Equine Business?
If your goal is to:
Launch a digital product
Host a clinic or event
Scale beyond 1:1 work
Or simply create more predictable, sustainable income
Then you need a warm audience. And that’s what email marketing helps you build.
I know it’s tempting to rely on social media. It is “free” after all. And it feels easier, faster, and more visible.
But, please remember this: Social media is rented space.
You don’t own your audience there.
Algorithms change and platforms disappear. Seemingly random accounts get flagged or shut down.
And just like that—you’ve lost access to the people you worked so hard to build trust with.
But, email is different. When someone joins your email list, you own that connection.
You have direct access to their inbox. No algorithm required.
Let’s take emotion out of it for a second and look at behavior:
60% of consumers prefer to be contacted by brands through email *
88% of email users check their inbox multiple times a day *
People don’t just prefer email. They engage with it daily.
Which means you have repeated opportunities to:
Build trust
Stay top of mind
And guide them toward working with you
Still Not Sure About Email Marketing for Your Horse Business?
If you’re on the fence, I’ve broken this down further in these resources:
Or, if you’re just getting started:
So… You Have Subscribers. Now What?
Let’s say you’ve done the work.
You have a form on your website. Maybe even a solid incentive that attracts the right people.
Now what? What happens after someone joins your email list?
How do you turn them from a casual subscriber into an actual client?
This is where your welcome sequence comes in.
A welcome sequence (also called a nurture sequence) in it’s simplest form is a series of automated emails sent after someone joins your list.
Typically, they’re spaced out over a few days.
A welcome sequence compresses trust-building. Instead of someone taking 3 months to get to know you, they can do it in 5 days. Which also means they’re in a place to make a buying decision that’s right for them even quicker.
What to Include in Your Welcome Sequence
Let’s keep this simple and practical. Here’s a basic breakdown of what to include in a welcome sequence for your equine business.
1. Set Expectations
Let them know what’s coming with something like: “Over the next few days, I’ll be sending you a few emails to help you ________…”
Also, remind them they always have permission to opt out. This builds trust right away and filters our people who discover they aren’t a good fit after all. (Remember, you don’t want them on your list, if that’s the case.)
2. Share Your Story
Who are you? Why do you do this work?
Let them connect with the human behind the business.
3. Show Them What You Do
This is where you bridge the gap by sharing a client story.
Explain how you help. Let them see themselves in the story.
4. Deliver Value (Your Best Content)
Send them your top blog posts, YouTube videos, podcast episodes, etc.
This is your “bingeable” content that builds relationship, delivers value, and positions you as the expert.
5. Invite Them to Work With You
This is where so many people miss the mark.
Be very clear about what the next steps are to work with you by providing a clear, specific call to action.
6. Segment Your Audience (Advanced Option)
This is more advanced but can be powerful as you grow.
Get to know your audience and target offers to them by using polls or surveys or even tracking what they click on in your welcome emails.
This helps you understand what they’re interested in and tailor your marketing moving forward.
But don’t overcomplicate things. This is just an option to keep in mind.
For now, here’s a simple welcome sequence you can start with:
Email 1: Deliver freebie + set expectations
Email 2: Your story + best content
Email 3: Client story + What you do
Email 4: Invitation to work with you
That’s it!
One Final Thing to Keep in Mind About Your Email Welcome Sequence
Automation is amazing. But, at the end of the day, don’t discount connection.
It doesn’t have to be fancy.
But in a world where everything feels automated (and, a little hard to believe, thanks to AI), seeing and hearing a real person builds trust fast.
Your Next Steps
If you don’t have a welcome sequence:
→ Map out 3–4 simple emails this week
If you already have one:
→ Audit it
Is it current? Does it feel like you and invite them to take the next steps?
Of course, you'll want to listen to the full episode to dig into each of the insights shared and discover how you can apply each one in your horse business!
Links Mentioned In This Episode
4 Steps to Build Your Email List with Qualified Leads [Episode 156]
Why Email Marketing Feels Like Spam & 3 Ways to Do It Well Instead [Episode 65]
Is Email Marketing Dead? 4 Email Marketing Myths Debunked [Episode 18]
FREE Beginner’s Guide to Email Marketing for Horse Businesses
✨ FREE The Equine Entrepreneur’s Roadmap to Grow a Sustainable Business Without Burning Out
Take the Reins: 1:1 Business Coaching for Equine Entrepreneurs: Craft and implement a clear strategy for your brand messaging, website, social media, and email marketing in my 1:1 coaching container.
The Business Barn Collective: The 6-month curated group coaching experience to grow your equine business sustainably, so you can do what you love for the long-term.
Rate, Review & Follow in Apple Podcast
‘I love How to Market Your Horse Business.’ <– If that sounds like you, please consider rating and reviewing my show! This helps me support more people (just like you) grow their horse business so they can be out in the barn doing what they love. Click here, scroll to the bottom, tap to rate, and select “Write a Review.” Then be sure to let me know what you loved most about the episode!
Not an Apple person? Other directories don't have a rate or review option right now, but you can still subscribe/follow! Click here for Google Podcasts or here for Spotify.
